Search
On Being Transgender, Part I
blog
Real World Dailies | Post | On Being Transgender, Part I
 
 
Post
Katelynn  created this post 19 months ago

Now that the show has aired I have fielded countless questions on what it means to be Transgender, and I’m amazed at the sheer amount of misinformation and ignorant stereotypes that are still largely pervasive about the LGBT community.  A great many of those stereotypes and misconceptions can be observed by daily comments right here on this site.  I knew it was bad, I just didn’t know it was this bad.

I’m going to begin my tirade with the “abomination of God” folks.  The typical, knee-jerk quip you will receive from these individuals is: “why can’t you be happy with the way God made you?”  If someone is born deaf, blind, or physically incapable of walking and there were medical procedures available to provide someone with the ability to hear, see, or walk again would you tell them to be happy with the way God made them?  To a lesser extent, are people who undergo Lasik eye surgery or a triple heart bypass defying the will of God?  I guess it’s only okay to have medically corrective surgery as long as they are restricted to myopic social norms.  This line of thought is also woefully presumptuous in that it assumes we all subscribe to the same narrow religious dogmas. 

I’m a naturalistic pantheist, not a monotheist.

The primary assault on my gender identity, however, comes in the form of “you were born male; you are always going to be male”.  Being that I am a scientist at heart we will deal with the science before the abstract.  I can honestly say that I have never had a Karyogram or any other karyotyping test done; I have no idea if I was born XY or XXY (for a long list of undisclosed medical reasons).  Genetics aside, there are some who believe I am male because I lack certain female reproductive organs.  So does a uterine cancer survivor cease to be a woman because she underwent a hysterectomy?  How about genetic and anatomic females who were born without ovaries?  My inability to birth a child is no different than countless women who are also unable to conceive.

When it comes to being Transgender, and this is almost always specifically from men, the reference to genitalia is usually described using the words “cut” and “off”.  During Gender Reassignment Surgery existing skin is refashioned into a beautiful and functional vulva and vagina; nothing is amputated.  Contrary to popular belief, there is more to being female than the lack of a penis; women have their own unique set of genitals that have nothing to do with male anatomy. These misogynists are also from the school of thought that women need not wear watches because the stove already has a clock.

The last bastion of the ignorant is “but you don’t look like a girl”.  I feel a great swell of pity for those who subscribe to an anorexic standard of beauty and think that being beautiful equates to some obscure measurement of my waist, hips, thighs, bust, or ass.  Women exist in all shapes and sizes, and beauty is not limited to the standards of Western civilization.  Anyone who feels the need to attack someone’s gender identity, or their value, through a superficial assessment is a lethargic devil and should look inward before wantonly casting judgment on another person.

There’s more I’d like to say on this matter, but this will have to suffice for now.

For more check out NewNowNext.com,
the gay pop culture & entertainment blog!


 
 
 
 
 
 
0%
 
 
 
 
Flag
URL: 
Comments
Hi Guest, Log In or Sign Up  to comment.

  • grrandram grrandram commented | 17 months ago
     
    Karena09-So what's your point? What did you think I was saying? I don't see how your response has anything to do with my comments. FYI, I'm a gay man.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • MasterLearner MasterLearner commented | 18 months ago
     
    Katelyn's comparison of being handicapped with being unhappy with your gender is ridiculous, son. I don't see any parallels. The first is a physical impairment, while the latter is a mental, spiritual and social deficiency.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Karena09 Karena09 commented | 18 months ago
     
    grrandram,

    It sounds like you haven't encountered a gay man before. I know a few, so let me tell you about them. Gay men, they like being MEN a lot. I mean, like a LOT. They like their masculinity so much, they seek it out in their partners. They are kind of not into the whole female thing and there's no way they want to be female.

    Straight (homophobic) men kind of think that emasculation is the worst thing possible, and somehow think gay men do that--I'm not really clear why they think that. The *real* gay men I know are very masculine (and very handsome and not complete a*******). Funny that.

    And that gets to the crux of the matter. A man cannot conceive of why anyone would want to be anything but a man, and so a man who changes into a female, a lower class citizen, is to be reviled. The funny thing is that men are MUCH more accepting of transsexuals in the other direction...female-to-male.

    BUT...I guess that isn't funny, they are just freeing themselves of their lowly female state, eh?
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Lindsey Lindsey commented | 18 months ago
     
    so you really think someone would go through years of counseling and put them selves in the smallest most persecuted minority in the world just so they can act like there someone they are not? that makes absolutlly no sense.... and what does a girl act like.... i never knew there were rules to how a girl must act...I guess because I like to shoot guns and play sports im acting like a boy? I find what you said insensitive and insulting to the entire female population... please please tell us what she does to act like a "gay man" was it when she was making out with that girl at the bar that she was acting like a gay man? please enlighte us....
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • grrandram grrandram commented | 19 months ago
     
    For starters, I don't really care what you have down there between your legs. Your argument about women who have hysterectomies doesn't equate with being transgendered because they were women from the beginning. Apparently you were born male, but somehow got to thinking you were really a woman. How could you know what it feels like to be a woman if you are a man? Were you straight when you were male? It seems that you were a gay man who wanted to become a woman. That is more believable and understandable than being a woman trapped in man's body. Actually, you still seem like a gay man trying to act like a girl. At least on television that's how it looks. But whatever, to each, their own. You have fun with it.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Fajita McJones Fajita McJones commented | 19 months ago
     
    Really, Katelynn? You didn't expect a lot of people to not understand the fine details of sexual reassignment surgery? Why would you? It's only an operation that is performed on an very small portion of the population and is rarely discussed openly by people who have been through the operation, but anyone who doesn't understand it and (incorrectly) assumes that some part must have been amputated in the process is automatically a misogynist? Did you not expect people to not understand this rare procedure and the people who undergo it when you became an advocate? Show a little more patience and don't think that anyone who doesn't know the fine details of being a transgendered person is a caveman who only views women as a source of dinner and babies. Someone doesn't need to know all the details of what happens in that surgery to proudly support the rights and freedoms of transgendered people and hearing you refer to them as misogynists will probably shut them down to anything good you might be able to teach them. Next time, be a little more patient and expect people who haven't had to do extensive reaserch on the procedure (most likely because they haven't needed it for themselves) to have some questions or assumptions about it that seem dumb to you.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Domo.Kun Domo.Kun commented | 19 months ago
     
    So I just recently watched Milk, and it really got me thinking about hate or prejudice towards people who are different from the norm. It's really hard to see that there still so much prejudice in our society, it's a shame that we think we're all civilized but this hate against the LGBT community, or any other minority group for that, still continues. It's really disheartening.
    But what makes up for it is when we have strong outspoken people like you Katelynn or anyone else who actually gives a rat's ass about equality, striving to get our community out of the mud, and get some bit of recognition.
    Reading your blog made my day ok
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Summer Summer commented | 19 months ago
     
    Katelynn, The one I hate is when people ask me if I'm pre or post op. My gender is way more than what's between my legs, and since when has it ever been normal to walk up to someone and ask them about their genitals? Why are these people so concerned about what's down there? Anyhow, I'm so glad to see trans people on TV especially when there's the opportunity to see that we're just like everyone else, and there's more to us than just our gender issues.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • actslikeablackgirl actslikeablackgirl commented | 19 months ago
     
    I love you Katelynn and you are soo beautiful! I can't even imagine all the heart ache you had to go through in life before and somewhat after the surgery. I absolutely LOVE your personality. I know that if I were in the house, I'd definitely gravitate more towards you just because you are more open. You and Sarah I'd LOVE to hang out with. Strong, beautiful and intelligent women!
     
    Flag