Search
On Being Transgender, Part II
blog
Real World Dailies | Post | On Being Transgender, Part II
 
 
Post
Katelynn  created this post 18 months ago

This blog entry is a continuation of a previous post, On Being Transgender, Part I

In this week’s episode the Kat is out of the bag as I finally come out to Devyn and Ryan confronts me about his suspicions.  Oh and I also make a fool of myself in Gettysburg, good times.  Episode six reminds me of a few times in my life where there were those close to me friends, co-workers, people I’d been dating who I knew had questions but I never addressed them until forced to do so.  And much like those times, this too was spawned by the rumors of a gossipy little devil who feels that everybody’s business is their business.  We also see the beginning of the divide between the sexes, one which at this point was a long time coming.

My conversation with Ryan was awkward and uncomfortable on its own merit and was only exacerbated by the presence of the hungry, gluttonous camera.  It feels odd and insulting to hear Ryan say that I am “so much more comfortable” because I finally “came clean” about my Transgender status.  As if to imply that I was at one point “dirty” because of it.  What aggravates me the most about his statement though is that it feeds into general assumption that Trans people need to disclose in order to have a friendship or relationship with someone.  That assumption is of course wrong.

My being Trans was never something I was trying to hide.  It’s a part of who I am, part of my life story, and is something that I typically reserve only for those I deem trustworthy and deserving.  If Sarah’s past had been extracted from her so viciously would you still agree that things were better because of it?  Or would you feel repulsed by the individual(s) talking behind her back, demanding that she reveal the most intimate and personal parts of herself?

You quick and dimwitted whose knee-jerk rebuttal is “now hold on, that’s not the same thing” can shut your mouths.  It is times like these wherein I lose faith in humanity.  Every time a new caveat to the human existence comes around it is treated the same way: you are different than I? I am King and you are peasant.  You are different than I? Woman is tantamount to property.  You are different than I? Your skin is pigmented and you are slave.  You are different than I? You will adhere to the standards I set, and I deem acceptable.  You are different than I?  You shall be beaten, raped, and murdered for walking your own path. For being different.

The audacity someone must have for being human, for thinking freely, for feeling and being true to themselves.

I hate to bring up a dead subject, but going back to the commentary I received on
the “African American” conversation, the “it’s always been that way” mentality.  “It’s always been that way, so why bother?”  Yes, why bother questioning anything?  Let us all lead a singular, cookie-cutter existence; we will be white-collar day-laborer suburbanites who struggle to keep up with the Joneses.  Different is bad, and we are taught bad is evil, and evil is to be smited.  So why question anything about our lives or the way things are?  What a simple and carefree existence it must be to be so blindly led by the hand.

Are you shocked by the anger in my words?  You shouldn’t be, for it was born of your actions; for every name on rememberingourdead.org, for every comment on this very site from the self-righteous who feel the need to correct my gender identity with their male pronouns, for every time some narrow-minded parasite tells me I am wrong for my “decision”.  Every bit of it a piece of kindling for my fire.

This is just a fraction of what I and those like me must face on a daily basis.  This is part of what it means to be Transgender.

 

Tune in to The Real World: Brooklyn Wednesdays at 10pm on MTV
And Check this never-before-seen footage of
Kat's trip to Thailand.

For more check out NewNowNext.com,
the gay pop culture & entertainment blog
!

 
 
 
 
 
 
0%
 
 
 
 
Flag
URL: 
Comments
Hi Guest, Log In or Sign Up  to comment.

  • Karena09 Karena09 commented | 17 months ago
     
    usucdik,

    I'm glad you agree that people like Katelynn should be fixed.

    Katelynn was given the option to fix her problem, and she did just that. She no longer has a female brain trapped in a male body. Her body is female to go with it.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Lindsey Lindsey commented | 17 months ago
     
    well changing the fuctions of someone's mind is not possible.... and i doubt the individual you would be wanting to change would want to be changed.... the reason people are closeted is because of their fear of ostracism and hatred....so if it were possible to just change people's minds then i would certainlly hope you would and all the other bigoted a.ss.hats would be the first ones in line!!!!
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • usucdik usucdik commented | 18 months ago
     
    Karena09,

    Plenty of gay people would like to be "fixed". Why do you think they're "in the closet" in the first place?

    Left-handedness is just a silly thing to bring up. That stuff was caused by ignorant myths, like shit in the bible.

    And yes, it is a problem with the brain that these weirdos have, and it would be nice if they or their parents were given the option to fix it. Considering all the stories flying around here about them committing suicide, I would hope you would have enough sense to realize that this is the best method.

    And no, it wouldn't be a lobotomy; you're an idiot for bringing that up.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • MasterLearner MasterLearner commented | 18 months ago
     
    @Tonguetwista, without realizing it, many people on this board are proving my point, by ignoring Katelyn's obvious hypocrisy. People are posting in large numbers in support of Katelyn's right to be defined as she wants. However, when Katelyn was infringing on Devyn's right to be defined as an "African-American", no one spoke out in support of Devyn. In fact, people sided with Katelyn, arguing that as a black woman, Devyn shouldn't be called what she wished. But here's the real zinger: The posters on this board are proving my most important point - that whites care very little about the freedoms of blacks. Even gay and transgendered rights are dubbed more important to whites than the rights and freedoms of blacks. Sad to say, this country that desires so much to put race behind it, still has a lot of racial hang-ups.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Karena09 Karena09 commented | 18 months ago
     
    usucdik stated:

    "Okay, so just a part of the brain has been identified as being similar in these cases, and all it implies is a correlation for now. If it is not substantial proportions of the brain following this trend, then it seems like it can be chalked up to a disorder or deformity, one which hopefully at some point could be identified and corrected when more is known about it."

    Yeah, sure, a full frontal lobotomy will "solve" most problems that people have. It will also solve their ability to think. Go watch "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest" and get back to us.

    Removing (or changing) the part of the brain that controls who each of us are is just plain wrong.

    Do you think gay people need to be "fixed" with an operation or a pill? Ask them if they want it. Then ask a transsexual how they would like to be "fixed". I bet it's not altering their brains. Our minds ultimately defines who we are and what we think.

    Our educational system used to "fix" left-handers, making them use their right hands. That makes a lot of sense.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • toungetwista toungetwista commented | 18 months ago
     
    I really didn't want to comment on this but I feel as if you guys are losing out out on the irony that MasterLearner pointed out. MasterLearner argument was that Kat has no right to try and define another person because she is facing the same situation. If Devyn felt comfortable calling herself African American, black or a ***** that's her right to do so. Same as Kat not having to be subjected by society labeling her with a "him". Its a double standard I can label myself how I feel and I don't want no one to question it but if you put a label on yourself I have all right to question and refute it.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Lindsey Lindsey commented | 18 months ago
     
    what he doesn' understand is that calling her a "him" is insulting to all transsexuals not just katelynn.... it's no different than calling malcom x the n word..... grow up master learner and quit bieng an a s s h a t
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Lindsey Lindsey commented | 18 months ago
     
    master learner has no common sense and is a horrible hate monger.... i will call him learner bin laden from now on...
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • MasterLearner MasterLearner commented | 18 months ago
     
    Melissa, religion became a part of this discussion when you used the phrase "eye for an eye". Therefore, if the conversation is 'irrational' sue to its biblical basis, you have yourself to blame. In either case, you shouldn't employ biblical phrases in instances in which you believe you can manipulate them to make a point when you really don't understand the phrase and the context in which it was originally used. That's why believers study the bible: for understanding, not as conversation pieces for debate.

    Moreover, you continue to operate under the false belief that retribution meted out by the oppressed against the oppressor is the result of ill-will in the oppressed person's heart. Rather, it is only a natural law of the universe that you reap what you sew, meaning if you treat others with contempt and malice, in turn you too will be treated with contempt and kindness. A friend of mine's words seem to resonate clear in my heart that "If somebody's going to make me feel uncomfortable, I'm going to make them feel uncomfortable too! I'm not going to be uncomfortable by myself.

    What is the alternative to 'eye for an eye'? Doing nothing, and remaining a willing participant in your own oppression? Allowing yourself to eternally be the victim who holds tightly to his moral convictions of non-retribution? Where did avoiding retribution get MLK? Six feet under with a bullet in his head.

    In order to use "eye for an eye" as a debate piece, you should first read the bible to understand the context in which Jesus used it. If you're not going to read the bible, then don't mention anything from it. Jesus' statements discouraging an eye for an eye were not spoken to everyone. They were only spoken to the Israelites, and referred to the Isralites turning their cheek to each other, not seeking revenge on their fellow Isrealite brethren. However, Jesus never told the Isrealites to be punching bags to outsiders. He, himself, sought retribution against the Pharasees and scribes. He kicked the table of the corrupt tax officers over. He was not a pacifist, he encouraged revolutionary action. In order to know any of this, you'd have to read the bible.

    Don't think that the "eye for an eye" philosophy is the only reason I'd call Katelyn a man. I only chose to express that because no one else noticed Katelyn's hypocrisy and how based on karma, she deserves every bit of discrimination she experiences because of her own discriminatory actions. But, in order to talk about my other reasons, I'd have to start talking about the creator, who you seem to find repulsing and irrelevant.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • MasterLearner MasterLearner commented | 18 months ago
     
    Melissa, surely you could agree that if Katelynn wants others to call her what she wishes to be called, she should, in turn, respect their wishes to be called what they want to be called, right? And surely, you could agree that her inability to accept others definition of themselves, makes it all the more ironic that she wants others to accept her as she defines herself: which is as a woman.

    Although you can't speak for, nor defend Katelyn's actions, I didn't see you on the "African American" board defending blacks' right to choose what they'd prefer to be called. Are gender identification issues more salient than racial identification issues or are you just more personally sympathetic to gender based issues? I'd love to hear how you justify the differential response of whites to issues that are all based on the same core problem.

    Furthermore, there is another biblical principle which states that "you reap what you sow." Katelyn labels others how she deems appropriate regardless of their wishes, therefore, she can expect to be labeled by the standards in which others deem appropriate in spite of her feelings.

    No, here's the problem with your "eye for eye" argument: For centuries, blacks like myself, have restrained ourselves from retaliating against the oppressive actions and practices of whites due to our call to be more "moral" than our oppressors. Believe me you, many foreigners are surprised that blacks and other oppressed minority groups haven't retaliated using the same tactics whites have (i.e. violence, ****, murder, manipulation, etc.). The problem with refraining from employing the eye for eye strategy in obtaining true freedom and equality is that it benefits those the dominant class, and guarantees that these subordinate groups remain powerless and oppressed. Only by giving an eye for an eye, will those who were originally oppressive feel the same amount of discomfort that the oppressed due. Likewise, only by refusing to call Katelyn a woman, will she begin to feel discomfort (the bible calls it being convicted). Then she will begin to reflect on how her refusal to call people what they wish to be called makes them feel. And she will, in turn, start respecting people's choices, and they will then respect her choice. But until that happens, Katelyn is a man in my eyes. And if I saw her in public, I'd call him Kenneth or Kyle, or Kevin.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Lindsey Lindsey commented | 18 months ago
     
    acctually they found that except for this part of the brain... no other part of the brain is different in males and females.. also they proved that taking hormones had no efect on this part of the brain changing if you read the whole article I think how they proved that was in there... but atleast it does show that transsexuals don't choose to be transsexuals...and im glad you have learned that if just one person's mind was changed then i feel great...
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • usucdik usucdik commented | 18 months ago
     
    Okay, so just a part of the brain has been identified as being similar in these cases, and all it implies is a correlation for now. If it is not substantial proportions of the brain following this trend, then it seems like it can be chalked up to a disorder or deformity, one which hopefully at some point could be identified and corrected when more is known about it.

    I do see arguments about whether this effect was induced somehow, and not a natural tendency. Some hormone treatments have produced other responses that blur the male and female distinction.


    Also Melissa, you're an idiot; shut up.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Lindsey Lindsey commented | 18 months ago
     
    acctually they had to disect cadaver brains but i will look up an article and post a link... we had to do indepth research on it in a psych class so yeah i will post it later.. are you saying it will change your opinion?

    http://jcem.endojournals.org/cgi/content/full/85/5/2034

    that one is a lil technical so i hope you can understand it lol if not just google transsexual brain lol

    p.s. also of course the entire brain is not identical just the part that diferentiates a female brain from a male brain
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • usucdik usucdik commented | 18 months ago
     
    I would be very pleased if you could show an article that includes brainscans showing how these different brains are "identical".

    My guess is you're full of horseshit and misconstruing a very small part of what something may have mentioned.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Karena09 Karena09 commented | 18 months ago
     
    Go get 'em, Kat!

    I thought Kat handled it very well. I hope she keeps trying. There are a lot of people out there who want to be educated in a conversation similiar to what she had with Ryan. Unfortunately, not everyone is willing to listen.

    I can't imagine what it's like to be cornered like that...Ryan's words in the episode saying "I need to be more aggressive"...was like...WTF? That's what most people call harrassment.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Lindsey Lindsey commented | 18 months ago
     
    science tends to disagree with you nunya. it's been shown that trans women and natal women have identical brains..... so how could she choose what brain she was given? I am pretty sure that a brain is a biological organ annnnnd is it not the biggest sex organ that humans have? So if her biggest sex organ is female then i guess i would say biologically she was born female ok I think everyone would apreciate if you made your statements in a manner not based on personal beliefs and illogical rhetoric and instead injected facts in to the discussion......

    THE TRUTH IS OUT THERE YOU JUST HAVE TO OPEN YOUR MIND
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Nunya Nunya commented | 18 months ago
     
    I'm sorry but the deep voice and the Adam's apple? c'mon...
    Ok here let me present this objectively as to how I came to my conclusion. Here are some key points: Was she physically born a girl?

    If so why did she need to get the physical surgery to render her one?

    If the answer to the first question is no then what does that make her before she got the surgery? How would you define her as physically before she got the surgery?
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • Nunya Nunya commented | 18 months ago
     
    No I'm sorry being born african american is different than choosing to be transgendered. For one thing you weren't born trans-gendered it was a choice. Its not like I woke up some day and said hey I think I'll be black today and for the rest of my life may I have the surgery? Yet that is tantamount to what you did Kat when you CHOSE that's right I said it CHOSE to be trans-gendered it was a CHOICE that you made.

    You chose this Kat no one forced you to do this. And if you wanted to you could choose to go back to the way you were that's still an option. You'll never truly understand where I'm coming from or anyone else who was born a race other than white or a gender other than male for that matter. For the record I'm male I was just using the latter point as a justified parallel. You were not born a woman you were born a man chose to become a woman then had the surgery because for whatever reason you just didn't feel right I don't know what your reason is but that is what it is.

    Cause deep down inside you're still male there are somethings that surgery will never be able to replace that still make you the white male you were born as. To say otherwise is to admit your own denial of who you are. Yes sure you've changed your outside and your voice but you're still the same person you were born as inside and that will never change. You will never truly change you're in denial if you think otherwise.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • usucdik usucdik commented | 18 months ago
     
    It's a dude, man. Don't get your oversized, fake panties in a bunch.
     
    Flag
     
     
     
  • grrandram grrandram commented | 18 months ago
     
    Melissa: okay. Will do.

    Lindsey: I never said she was a guy. I never called her a guy. I've always referred to her as "she". This topic came up because Katelynn made a comment that she didn't feel she had to disclose herself to people with whom she becomes friends or has relationships. I agreed that she didn't NEED to tell anybody, but if I wasn't told she was transgendered, I would just think she was a gay guy. That's all. MelissLA is the one who called their lives "life styles".

    Anonymous32: Again, I never said: "if i didnt know you i would have assumed you were a (insert words above)". That's what I like about you the most: your anger.
     
    Flag